Newspapers' data analysis finds that Kentucky's seniors on Medicare are among the sickest in U.S.; local data available

Red counties are over 21%. For map with data, click here.

The top 10 Kentucky counties with the highest percentage of seniors on Medicare who have six or more chronic conditions are also in the nation's top 50 for sick seniors, according to government data analyzed by USA Today and The Courier-Journal. Nine of the top 10 counties are in Appalachia.

"That's not surprising," Fran Feltner, director of the University of Kentucky Center of Excellence in Rural Health, told The C-J's Laura Ungar. "And when you're having breathing problems, high blood pressure problems and other problems, to me it seems like you're waging a daily battle against the chronic diseases. It's hard to fight the battle ... and as you get older, it's harder."

The top 10 Kentucky counties ranked by percentage of the 65-and-older Medicare population with six or more chronic conditions are Clay, 27.1 percent; Breathitt, 26.3 percent; Johnson, 26.2 percent; Knott, 25.1 percent; Perry, 24.6 percent; Letcher, 24.2 percent; Bell, 24 percent; Floyd, 23.8 percent; Wolfe, 23.7 percent; and Taylor, 23.6 percent. Taylor County (Campbellsville) is not in Appalachia but borders three non-coal Appalachian counties.

Beve Cotton (C-J photo by Mark Mahan)

Beve Cotton, 81 and with a long list of chronic diseases, is one of those seniors. He lives in Manchester, the seat of Clay County, which ranks 12th among more than 3,100 counties nationally for the percentage of seniors on Medicare with six or more chronic conditions, Ungar reports.

"I'm a mess," said Cotton, who gets around in a power chair and wears a full set of dentures after losing all his teeth. "I'm not able to do things. I'm an accomplished cook, but I can't do that anymore ... I can't drive. My legs don't cooperate. ... It's very hard."

Ungar reports that Clay County, population 21,147, has many of the factors that combine to cause poor health.: "Nearly 38 percent of residents live below the poverty level, compared with a state average of 19 percent, according to the Census Bureau. Median household income is about $22,000 a year, about half the state average.Access to health care, especially specialists, is limited, and there are few well-stocked grocery stores or safe places to exercise. Smoking and obesity rates are sky-high."

Carmen Webb, who directs the senior center in Manchester, told Ungar that many seniors struggle with being able to afford staples, let alone healthy food and also the high cost of transportation, making it difficult to get to doctors appointments to manage their illnesses.

Cotton, who grew up in Manchester, told Ungar that he depends on others for rides, frequently to doctors' appointments, including many at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Lexington, about 100 miles away. Webb noted that public transportation in the area costs $1.50 per mile.

Feltner added that many seniors in the area don't know how to prevent chronic disease, some have fatalistic attitudes and because many of them are on multiple medications, they face the dangers of drug interactions and side effects, Ungar reports.

Experts say that such high levels of illness hurts communities, "hastening a downward economic spiral locally and requiring huge portions of Medicare budgets," Ungar writes. It also overtaxes the medical communities in rural counties even thinner.

"These patients need to be seen frequently by doctors, and they need much longer visits. ... These folks need intense care," Dr. Michael Karpf, executive vice president for health affairs at UK, told Ungar. "Given the shortage of primary care in Appalachia, this kind of patient just exacerbates that shortage."

"The real issue is prevention — weight control, exercise, food habits," Karpf said. "But it's hard. Fast food is cheaper than wholesome, healthy food, and (the way people eat) is partly cultural. Those things are hard to change. It's a generational process."

'Medicaid Dashboard' gives county-by-county details on 375,000 who joined program, what screenings they got, what they found

The expansion of the federal-state Medicaid program under federal health reform marks the biggest change in Kentucky health care since Medicare began in the mid-1960s. Almost 400,000 people have joined the program, raising its rolls to more than one-fourth of the state's population. This is an important story in almost every county, and the state has the data to tell it.

As part of the $141,000 study of the first year of Medicaid expansion, Deloitte Consulting created for the state and its citizens a "Medicaid Dashboard" that gives detailed information about the newly eligible Medicaid enrollees in every county, by age, gender and chronic health conditions, along with information about payments to health-care providers in each county. Here's a partial screenshot, with one county highlighted:

And here's an example of how data from that county can be broken down by age and gender:

In addition to these data, and detailed information about payments to providers, the dashboard also reveals how many new Medicaid enrollees have been diagnosed with what chronic conditions, and what screenings and other preventive services they have received. This can also be broken down by county. For the dashboard, go here.

The data are only for people who were made eligible for Medicaid by the expansion, which raised the income limit to 138 percent of the federal poverty line, from 69 percent. The data do not include several thousand people who had been eligible for Medicaid under the old limit but did not enroll until the limit was raised.

At least 14 counties had vaccination rates in 2011-12 below level experts say is needed to protect kindergartners from measles

As concern about the spread of measles from lack of vaccination grows, many Kentucky counties probably have vaccination rates below the minimum that experts say is needed to create "herd immunity" and prevent spread of the highly contagious disease among students in kindergarten.

At least 14 Kentucky counties had measles vaccination rates below 90 percent in the 2011-12 school year, according to state data analyzed by USA Today, in a survey of states that track vaccination rates and make them public. The Courier-Journal published the Kentucky figures in an online database.

The counties under 90 percent were Bath (89%), Boyle (83%), Bullitt (88%), Christian (89%), Harlan (88%), Jefferson (86%), Laurel (85%), Lawrence (88%), Lee (80%), Nelson (82%), Robertson (88%), Rowan (86%), Taylor (82%) and Webster (86%). Data from several counties was not available. For the database with county-by-county figures, click here.

The statewide vaccination rate was 93 percent, pulled down by a rate of 86 percent in Jefferson County, the state's most populous. The lowest rates were 80 percent in Lee County and 82 percent in Nelson and Taylor counties.

Jefferson County officials told The Courier-Journal that the county's rate rose above 90 percent in the last two to three years. Bullitt County school-health coordinator Lesa Bodine told the Louisville newspaper that her data show 94.3 percent of the county's kindergarten students "have been properly immunized," The C-J's Darla Carter reports. "However, she said there are some parents who choose not to immunize their children. She also noted that there can be a delay in receiving proof of vaccination because a child has, for example, transferred from another county or state."

Like many states, Kentucky allows parents to exempt their children from required vaccinations for medical or religious reasons. Measles outbreaks in other states have been blamed at least partly on parents who still believe discredited reports that vaccines cause autism or other disorders. Generally, the stricter the laws, the higher the vaccination rate, Stateline reports. Here's a Stateline map showing how states differ:

U of L plans to create statewide health institute with $4 million, three-year grant from KentuckyOne Health hospital firm

The University of Louisville is creating an institute to improve Kentucky's health through research, education and advocacy of health policies.

KentuckyOne Health is giving the university $4 million over three years to establish the Commonwealth Institute of Kentucky in U of L's School of Public Health and Information Sciences. Dean Craig Blakely said the institute will work in western Louisville but also on statewide issues, focusing on data gathering and analysis.

"Kentucky has the nation's highest rates of cancer deaths and smoking, and ranks among the top for cardiovascular disease, obesity, prescription drug abuse and other health problems," Laura Ungar notes for The Courier-Journal. "And certain neighborhoods, regions and populations suffer disproportionately, with even higher rates."